updated 4/9/14  (make sure to "refresh" this page)

CRITIQUES OF OTHERS ARE DUE ON BLACKBOARD BY

MIDNIGHT WEDNESDAY, 4-12.

--you use the "comment" option to post your critique--

IF ALL OF YOUR CRITIQUES ARE NOT COMPLETED BY THEN YOU LOSE THE CHANCE TO EARN 74 POINTS AND RECEIVE, INSTEAD, -100 WITH NO CHANCE TO MAKE THIS UP, BECAUSE YOUR CRITIQUES ARE OF NO USE TO OTHERS AFTER THEY HAVE WRITTEN THEIR PAPERS. YOUR COLLEAGUES ARE RELYING ON YOU: DON'T LET THEM DOWN.


GRADING OF YOUR EVALUATIONS OF OTHERS: THE FIRST FIVE EVALUATIONS ARE WORTH UP TO SIX POINTS (30 POINTS). EACH EXTRA EVALUATION YOU DO IS WORTH UP TO FIVE POINTS (THUS YOU COULD EARN UP TO 80  POINTS IF YOU CRITIQUED THE TWELVE OTHER STUDENTS AS  WELL). .

THE STUDENTS YOU EVALUATE WILL ALSO BE PRINTING OUT YOUR EVALUATIONS TO INCLUDE IN THEIR FINAL VERSIONS OF THEIR ESSAY.

  IF, WHEN THE INSTRUCTOR EVALUATES THE REVISED VERSION OF THE ESSAY YOU CRITIQUED, HE FINDS HUGE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN YOUR EVALUATION AND HIS, HE WILL THEN REDUCE YOUR CRITIQUE GRADE ACCORDINGLY.

TO GET CREDIT FOR YOUR CRITIQUES YOU MUST PUT ALL YOUR EVALUATIONS INTO A SINGLE WORD DOCUMENT (INCLUDING, OF COURSE, THE NAME OF EACH STUDENT YOU EVALUATED AT THE TOP OF THAT CRITIQUE). PRINT OUT THIS DOCUMENT AND HAND IT IN TO THE INSTRUCTOR WHEN YOU GET A CHANCE.


NAME  ON THE LEFT, below "PROJECT BY" = subject of peer critique, THAT IS, = THE ESSAY YOU ARE SUPPOSED TO CRITIQUE

names to the right, below "REVIEWER"= assignments for peer critiques (usually five each), that is: your name is to the right of the projects you are supposed to critique. If there is no project available to critique under a person's name, just keep choosing someone else until you reach the number you want.

You can do more, after you have done your rrquired five evaluations.

THE CRITERIA FOR YOUR CRITIQUES IS HERE, including A (basic requirements)

PROJECT BY

REVIEWER 1

REVIEWER 2

REVIEWER 3

REVIEWER 4

REVIEWER 5

BEE W, C, PR  A

AMANDES; C.

TIMBER WOLF

OWL

DOLPHIN

BLACK BEAR

TIMBER WOLF

ORCA PR, W, C  A

CARLISLE; RYAN

BEE

OWL

DOLPHIN

BLACK BEAR

WHITE HORSE

CRAB PR, W, C, A

DAVIDSON; DYLAN 

ORCA

BEE

DOLPHIN

BLACK BEAR

RAVEN

ELEPHANT W, C, PR, A

EMBREY; SHELBIE 

CRAB

ORCA

BEE

BLACK BEAR

SEA HORSE

SEA OTTER Pr, W, C, A

GUNN; CHARLOTTE 

ELEPHANT

CRAB

ORCA

BEE

BLACK BEAR

COYOTE W, S, C, A

HALL; ALISHA 

SEA OTTER

ELEPHANT

CRAB

ORCA

BEE

MILK SNAKE ,

A, ^ (COHERENCE, ESP. TRANSITIONAL PHRASES), PR, W

HOLMES; MADELYN

COYOTE

SEA OTTER

ELEPHANT

CRAB

DOLPHIN

HUMMINGBIRD ^, O, C A

KLEIN; LAURA

MILK SNAKE

COYOTE

SEA OTTER

ELEPHANT

CRAB

WHITE HORSE O, Doc, W A

MUNOZ; SEBASTIAN

HUMMINGBIRD

MILK SNAKE

COYOTE

SEA HORSE

ELEPHANT

SEA HORSE W, C, S A

PENNINGTON; ELLEN

WHITE HORSE

HUMMINGBIRD

MILK SNAKE

COYOTE

SEA OTTER

RAVEN O (includes paragraphing), C, W A

SANCHEZ; SANTIAGO 

SEA HORSE

WHITE HORSE

HUMMINGBIRD

MILK SNAKE

COYOTE

TIMBER WOLF P, W, C A

SOWERS; DANE 

MILK SNAKE

RAVEN

SEA HORSE

WHITE HORSE

HUMMINGBIRD

OWL Pr, W, C A

STORLI; ERIKA

TIMBER WOLF

SEA OTTER

RAVEN

SEA HORSE

WHITE HORSE

DOLPHIN  Doc, O, C A

STOUFFER; KATHRYN .

ORCA

OWL

TIMBER WOLF

HUMMINGBIRD

RAVEN

BLACK BEAR  ^, W, C A

WHITWORTH; EMMA

OWL

DOLPHIN

OWL

TIMBER WOLF

RAVEN