A look at Congress before Video 1 of the Power
Game
- But first the news:
Two Years Ago:
- National Intelligence Estimate,
The Analysis: On the
‘Polarization’ of Iraqis and Their ‘Ready Recourse to Violence’
NYT Feb 3, 2007
- Hamas
Fighters Appear to Tighten Hold in Gaza NYT Feb 3, 2007
- Science
Panel Calls Global Warming ‘Unequivocal’ NYT Feb 3,
2007
- John Pilger,
Iran; A
War is Coming, Feb 1, 2007, published in New Statesman,
Feb. 3, 2007.
-
Previous year:
From last time: Arab nationalism and the Eisenhower Doctrine
- read Little, pp. 163-185 - esp p177-8
John F. Kennedy (1961-63) on nationalism - another New Frontier
- Senator JFK on Algeria 1957, contrast with Eisenhower support
of monarchies.
- But Bay of Pigs 1961
- Cuba
missiles crisis Oct 16-28, 1962 (eventually Turkey-based
Jupiter missiles would also be removed)
- New relationship with Arab nationalism, Badeau to Cairo (where
High Dam USSR), PL 480 wheat and thaw in US-Egypt, JFK
honeymoon...
- Walt Rostow economic development "take-offs"...restraint of US
in Arab Cold War...
- Yemen coup 26 Sept 1962 - Nasser's unity of goals (after
Syrian UAR breakup 1961) and support of Yemen's new REPUBLIC;
Nasser's forces to the rescue seen as threat to OIL MONARCHIES...
So US recognition of Republic of Yemen? And disengagement of Egypt
and Saudi Arabia? US recognized Yemen Dec 19, 1962.
- Kennedy New Frontier: assurances to Saudi Arabia, show of US
air power (Egypt had bombed Najran), and "...I am confident that
Saudi Arabia will move ahead successfully on the path of
modernization and reform..."
Congress: Under the
Constitution
Congress has not only the power of the purse but also the power to
declare war and "advise and consent" on the appointment of
ambassadors and other matters. Under the Cold War consensus the
executive branch increased its power at the expense of congress.
- Recall, for instance, that the Senate defeated League of
Nations
treaty...three
times in 1919-20
- Expansion of presidential power: 1936 Supreme Court case
United
States vs. Curtiss-Wright Corp. used to justify FDR's Exec Agreement to
send 50 destroyers to Britain in September 1940 .
- 1940-41: Lend Lease Act of March 1941 was barely passed...
- Selective Service Act passed by 1 vote!
The Senate and treaties:
- treaties (which require Senate vote) have largely been
displaced by exec agreements that do not require any Senate
ratification.
- According to a 1984 study by the Senate Committee on
Foreign Relations, "88.3 percent of international agreements
reached between 1946 and 1972 were based at least partly on
statutory authority; 6.2 percent were treaties, and 5.5 percent
were based solely on executive
authority."(Senate
online source)
Congress to declare war?
(Constitution
I:8) - cf Perpetual
Peace (1795)
- June 1950 Korea War - "usurpation" of congressional war power
or a police action?
- Enehower: Indochina? No, but covert actions (Iran, Guatemla,
Cuba) OK.
- Gulf of Tonkin Resolution of Aug 7, 1964.
- Look, too, at how Congress has tried to display its authority
since the 1970s - with the
War Powers
Resolution (Joint Resolution of Nov. 7, 1973) requiring notice
within 48 hours but up to 90 days of fighting without a
congressional vote.
- Look at Louis Fisher,
Expansion of the
President's War Power, for further details about congress vs.
president.
You should also examine congressional cttees relevant to foreign
policy, i.e. Richard Lugar Senate Foreign Relations Ctte...re South
African sanctions in 1985 or so, also Philippines Aquino/Marcos
crisis....and J.W. Fulbright (d. 1995).
You may also find current chairs of
important
committees
And here, if you care to download, is part I of Hedrick Smith's
Power Game video - (360
megs)
Main page
Feb 9, 2009
Department of
Government,
College of Liberal
Arts, University of Texas at
Austin.
Questions, Comments, and Suggestions to
chenry@mail.utexas.edu